DWDaniel WallerEngineering. Leadership. Stories.
All Factory Floor stories

Lessons from the Factory Floor / 19

Sometimes the Repair Isn’t Enough

One of the more unusual incidents I've dealt with started with what looked like a simple water leak.

The toilet waste pipes had been routed through the roof void when the factory was originally built.

One day, a cold-water pipe snapped.

Every time someone flushed a toilet, more foul water was pumped into the roof space.

By the time the first ceiling panel started to leak, the roof void was completely full.

The only option was to stop production immediately.

For the next three days, the engineering team worked in waterproof suits, gloves and masks, removing contaminated water, cleaning the roof void and making the area safe before production could resume.

Once everything was cleaned, we had a choice.

We could simply replace the damaged pipe and restore the system exactly as it had been.

Or...

We could ask a better question.

"Why are sewage pipes running through the roof void in the first place?"

Instead of repairing the old design, we rerouted the pipework externally, removing the risk altogether.

It cost more.

It took longer.

But we left the site safer than we found it.

That experience taught me something I've carried throughout my career.

As engineers, it's easy to focus on getting a machine—or in this case, a building—back up and running.

As engineering leaders, our responsibility is bigger than that.

Sometimes the best repair isn't fixing what failed.

It's making sure it can never fail in the same way again.

What design flaw have you removed rather than simply repaired?