DWDaniel WallerEngineering. Leadership. Stories.
All Factory Floor stories

Lessons from the Factory Floor / 20

When Plan A Is Stolen

I've dealt with some unusual engineering problems over the years. But somebody stealing 400 metres of railway track is definitely up there.

Yes, you read that correctly. 400 metres of railway track. Gone. And as if that wasn't enough, they'd also helped themselves to three 150kVA generators.

One of our sites was situated alongside a railway line. We no longer manufactured anything there, but the buildings were still being used to store finished product ready for customer deliveries.

Then one morning, we arrived to discover that somebody had been rather busy. Over 400 metres of track had disappeared. Along with the three generators supplying electricity to the site.

I still struggle to understand how you go about stealing that much railway track without somebody noticing. It's not exactly something you can slip into your jacket on the way out.

But there we were. No power. No security. And a site full of finished product that we now had very little ability to monitor.

We had a problem. And replacing everything that had been stolen wasn't going to happen overnight. So we had to think differently.

Our immediate priority wasn't getting the site back to how it had been. It was making sure nobody came back and helped themselves to anything else.

Normally, installing CCTV would have been an obvious answer. One small problem. We didn't have any electricity. The generators had been stolen.

So we started looking at alternatives. And eventually, we installed a solar-powered monitored security system. No reliance on the site's electricity supply. And we could monitor what was happening without needing to be physically present.

It turned out to be a very good decision. Because not long afterwards, the same group returned to scout the site again. Only this time... We were watching. The new system captured them on camera before they had the opportunity to cause any further damage.

And that was the real success. Not replacing what we'd lost. But protecting what we still had.

I've thought about that incident a few times over the years. Because in engineering, our natural instinct is often to restore something to its original condition. A machine breaks. We repair it. A component fails. We replace it. A system stops working. We get it running again. And most of the time, that's exactly what we need to do.

But occasionally, the circumstances change so dramatically that the original solution is no longer the right one. And that's when you have to stop asking how to put everything back. And start asking what you actually need the system to do.

We didn't need to replace the entire electrical infrastructure to solve our immediate security problem. We needed a way to protect the site. And once we looked at it that way, a different solution became possible.

Lesson #20: Don't become so attached to restoring the original system that you overlook a better way of solving the problem. Sometimes the best engineering decision isn't about repairing what's broken. It's about adapting to what's changed.